row2k Features
Rowing and 'The Social Network'
Part III: Those Guys are Freakin' Fast
October 6, 2010
Dan Boyne

Henry Roosevelt during filming; photo: Will White

If you have never read a Hollywood script before, it is an exercise worth doing at least once. Straight off you will be amazed at how little there is to hang a story on outside of the dialogue. This places a heavy burden on the director, the actors, and the screenwriter.

I’d certainly heard about Aaron Sorkin, the famous screenwriter, but I’d never watched an episode of “The West Wing,” the TV series that helped launch his career. In addition to the task of rounding up a slew of talented oarsmen, I was also told to look over the script and see if there was anything that stuck out or looked awkward.

While I liked the non-linear flow of Sorkin’s script, which moved back and forth between court room deposition scenes and the narrative leading up to it, I was somewhat put off by the overly clever dialogue - particularly the lines he put into the mouths of Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss.

The Winklevoss Twins (or “Winklevi”) are the identical twins that rowed heavyweight crew at Harvard back in 2004. They are characters in their own right, but perhaps not as fleet of tongue as Aaron Sorkin made them out to be in the film.

No one is, I suppose; but Sorkin clearly didn’t know much about rowing.

One scene had the twins handily beating a pack of other Harvard pairs while they derided their teammates in a long-winded, snarky way. Tyler suggested that they row in a circle to give the other boats a chance, while Cameron suggested jumping out of the boat and swimming.

All of this witty repartee, of course, was delivered while they were rowing at full pressure.

I politely tried to explain to David Fincher & Co. that oarsmen generally didn’t speak in long, cleverly wrought sentences like this - not for lack of intellect but lack of breath.

Also, in an earlier part of the same scene the script had one of the other Harvard oarsmen turning around and delivering the line: “Those guys are freakin’ fast. I guess we’re not going to catch them today!”

This last snippet of dialogue was used as the try-out line during the Boston casting call for rowing extras, which was held at the Community Rowing Boathouse courtesy of director Bruce Smith. Ironically, Bruce and I had first met many years earlier when he was working on a film based loosely on “The Amateurs.”

About thirty guys showed up for twenty spots (two eights worth, plus a pair). One guy among the twenty would be the lucky one to deliver the dubious line of Aaron Sorkin’s dialogue. What it meant was a minuscule shot at fame and a substantial pay increase.

Where did most of the oarsmen come from?

There were several Harvard graduates, including ex-national team member Adam Holland, three or four Northeastern grads, and one from BU. From out of town there was an ex-stroke from Trinity by the name of Perrin Hamilton, and another from George Washington named Henry Roosevelt. There were also a smattering of club rowers from Union and Riverside.

Everyone wanted to be famous, but first they had to fill out some forms, have their picture taken, and perform for the casting director in a little room upstairs.

After the try out, nearly all the guys who emerged from the casting room concluded that the line of dialogue was super-corny and had to go.

Even oarsmen have their standards.

In case you are wondering, the average “extra” receives about $125 day on a Hollywood set, which isn’t much considering what you have to do. But I knew that the oarsmen were specialists and should get more pay, particularly when they were going to be out on the Charles in late October, sitting and waiting to perform take after take.

I explained to the guys that the romance of film was illusory and the actual work was pure tedium. They would be on call 24/7, and plans and practices would change randomly.

Then there were the rowing tryouts. While I knew at least half of the guys, the rest were total strangers with untested skills.

A few guys were out of shape, a few others were not strong or skillful enough, but overall there was some real talent. It is always exciting to watch a group of experienced oarsmen take to the water for the first time. It was like throwing jazz musicians together and seeing what kind of music would result.

I felt a little badly for Henry Roosevelt, who I’d placed in a pair with Adam Holland. During the casting call, I’d teased Henry about his lack of upper body bulk and pointed to the ultra-fit Holland. Adam played along, flexing his biceps. “You need to start lifting,” Holland chided him.

Henry, who had deep set, soulful eyes, just looked down, a little embarrassed.

But the casting director actually preferred Henry, who had studied acting after college instead of going to the gym. He got the speaking part, which meant he would make three times more than everyone else.

In Hollywood, sometimes muscles don’t win the day.

To be continued...


See and purchase Dan's books on rowing here:
  • Kelly, A father, a son, and American Quest
  • Red Rose Crew
  • Essential Sculling
    If you enjoy and rely on row2k, we need your help to be able to keep doing all this. Though row2k sometimes looks like a big, outside-funded operation, it mainly runs on enthusiasm and grit. Help us keep it coming, thank you! Learn more.


    Log in to comment
    10/08/2010  12:17:29 PM
    Nice pieces. Interesting to hear a little of the background on how those scenes came to fruition. My only question is why didn't anyone tell Fincher that rowers don't say "I row crew"? I totally bought it when Mark Zuckerberg and his girlfriend used that phrase, but when the Winklevi did it, my skin crawled.

    Otherwise I have to say the rowing was depicted about as realistically as I have ever seen (aside from the full sentences during full pressure pieces, of course).

    10/11/2010  10:02:46 PM
    Yeah I couldn't agree with you more. My friends and I who all row saw the movie and there was a gasp of digust when we heard that one line. I have to say this movie is becoming my favorite. The Henley scene was absolutely beautiful and it was even made more awesome by the fact that I was there last year.

    10/13/2010  8:19:00 AM
    The Henley scene was beautifully done, but it seemed a tad too slow. Races by elite and collegiate athletes just do not move that slow when you watch them.

    I also cringed at the "I row crew." line. Too novice-y. I agree with the article, though- that exchange between the Winklevosses is too casual for rowing a good, solid steady state piece. Too much talking while rowing.

    Get our Newsletter!

    Support row2k!

    Tremendous thanks to our
    row2k supporters!

    Get Social with row2k!
    Like row2k on Facebook Follow row2k on Twitter Follow row2k on Instagram Follow row2k on Youtube Connect with row2k on LinkedIn

    Get the row2k app!

    row2k rowing store!

    Get our Newsletter!
    Enter your email address to receive our weekly newsletter.

    Support row2k!

    Advertiser Index
    Advertise on row2k